After having agreed on all the financial, legal and technical
issues, the regional manager of Trans-Oceanic, Mr Ted Goodfellow,
went to Riyadh to wrap up the final details and to sign
the contract with Arabco. During the meeting with the top
Arabco executives Goodfellow said casually, "We, at
Trans-Oceanic, are really looking forward to working with
you here in the Persian Gulf!" At that there was a
moment of shocked silence on the Arabco side of the conference
table. Then the three senior executives arose and strode
angrily out of the room, breaking off negotiations. Bewildered
Goodfellow looked at the two junior Saudis who had remained
behind. "What happened here?" he asked the young
Arabs across the table. "Did I say something wrong?"
After some hesitation one of the Arabco employees explained
that in Saudi Arabia, the body of water in question is called
Arabian Gulf. By misnaming it Goodfellow had unintentionally
implied that the gulf belonged to Iran - a country which
Saudi Arabia at that time considered hostile and threatening.
Such misunderstandings are rampant when companies do business
globally. And to iron out such creases in the fabric of
relationships it is essential for the executives to be alert
to the cross-cultural differences that can wreck even the
most promising business deals.
Culture differs across the globe along with the shift of
latitudes and longitudes, along with the variations of the
hair colour and changes of the bone structures. Thus, in
Singapore, if the lift operator asks you at 7.30 AM, "Have
you had your lunch", politely answer "Yes, thank
you. Have you had yours?" To site an example of such
a cultural variation, if you go to Russia, do not feel uncomfortable
if a fellow Russian enfolds you in a great bear hug and
kisses you on your lips. While thumbs-up sign is slowly
emerging as a universal sign for "great", to many
Europeans and in the Middle East, it is an obscene sign.
Talking loudly, using hand gestures and facial expressions,
which comes quite normally to many, can easily make the
Thai women feel that you are furious or insane. Thus, behavior
that is proper and familiar in one culture may be rude,
offensive and strange at the other. And these contrasting
values may cause conflict at the conference table. To avoid
such blunders, it is absolutely essential for the international
business travelers to go through the travails of learning
the cultural basics of the country with which they are expected
to interact. Some of the aspects of the varied patterns
and hues of cross-cultural behaviors have been described
hereunder.
The "Great Divide" between cultures
The differences between the deal-focused (DF) people who
are fundamentally task-oriented and relationship-focused
(RF) folks, who are more people-oriented is considered to
be the "Great Divide" between business cultures.
Conflicts are common when DF export marketers make an effort
to do business with the RF markets. While the RF people
find the DF types aggressive, authoritative and offensively
blunt, the latter find the former dilatory, vague and inscrutable.
Attributes of those for whom deal comes first:
* Common in only a small part of the world. Strongly DF
cultures are found in Northern Europe, North America, Australia
and New Zealand, where people are relatively open to doing
business with strangers (See Box 1).
* Relatively open to dealing with strangers; export marketers
can normally make direct contacts with potential buyers
without any previous relationship or connection.
* Talk business right from the start and get to know each
other as things proceed; build rapport right at the bargaining
table.
* Business negotiations last for a shorter while.
* Much communication and problem solving is handled via
telephone, fax and e-mail rather than in face-to-face meetings.
* Rely more on written agreements to prevent misunderstandings
and solve problems. For instance, many US companies bring
a lengthy draft contract and a lawyer to the negotiating
table.
Attributes of those for whom relationship comes first:
* Prefer to deal with family, friends and groups who are
beyond suspicion.
* Get things done through intricate networks of personal
contacts and are uncomfortable about doing business with
strangers. The vast majority of world's markets are relationship-oriented:
the Arab world and most of Africa, Latin America and Asia-Pacific
region (See Box 1).
|
Box 1
The Great Divide
|
| Deal focused cultures |
Moderately deal-focused
cultures |
Relationship-focused
cultures |
North America, Australia,
Nordic and Germanic Europe,
New Zealand |
Great Britain, South Africa,
Latin Europe, Central and
Eastern Europe, Chile, South Brazil, North Mexico,
Hong Kong, Singapore |
The Arab world, most of Africa,
Latin America and Asia |
* Proper way to approach someone who does not yet know
you is to arrange for the right person or organization to
introduce you. A third-party introduction bridges the relationship
gap between you and the person/company you want to talk
to (See Box 2). Often the best way to contact RF business
partners is at an international trade show or to join an
official trade mission.
* In the "getting to know you" game, at the initial
stage, meeting hovers around discussing weather, sports,
music etc and often ends up without a single mention of
business. It takes time, patience and a cast-iron liver
(as, in many a case, getting inebriated together seems to
speed up the rapport-building process) to develop a strong
relationship.
* Business negotiations last for a long while.
* People rely more on personal relationships rather than
on lawyers and detailed contracts. It is better to keep
lawyers only in the background until the last stages of
discussion. A reliance on close relationships
* Effective communication and problem solving require frequent
face-to-face contacts.
|
box 2
Opening an office in Dhaka without paying bribes
| When an American company decided
to open a outsourcing and quality-control office
in Bangladesh, they were told by the local consulting
firms that the approval process would take up
to a year and the quoted fees was $ 10,000 including
"special expenses" - bribes to the responsible
officials. Unwilling to engage in bribery, the
firm shelved the idea of a Dhaka office. In the
later years, the firm's regional director for
South and South-East Asia met a charming, well-read
gentleman who had headed two different ministries
in a previous Bangladesh government and discussed
the problem with him. The latter promised to arrange
to get his office registered within a month. The
fee asked for was $900, the cost of the airfare.
Three weeks later their Dhaka office was a legal
entity - the fastest liaison-office registration
ever recorded in Bangladesh. |
|
Communicating across the Great Divide
These two sections vary immensely in the way they communicate.
DF negotiators are found to value direct, frank, straight-forward
language while their RF counterparts favour a more indirect,
subtle, roundabout style.
Attributes of direct language preference of deal-focused
people
* Priority is to be clearly understood.
* Usually say what they mean and mean what they say. For
example, German and Dutch negotiators are found to be blunt
speakers. They smile only when they need to and do not hesitate
to say a straight and polite "no".
* Have a transparent face that does not make much of an
effort to conceal expressions.
* Their communication is regarded as "low context"
i.e. more of the meaning is explicit - contained in words
themselves.
* Directness and frankness in communication are equated
with honesty and sincerity. Little attention is paid to
issues of face.
* A sincere friend is considered to be one who tells you
the truth even when the truth happens to be unpleasant.
Attributes of indirect language preference of relationship-focused
people
* Priority is to maintain harmony and to promote smooth
interpersonal relationship.
* Tend to use indirect language to avoid conflict and confrontation.
They carefully watch what they do or say in order to avoid
embarrassing or offending other people.
* Most Japanese, Chinese and South East negotiators treat
"no" as an insulting word (See box No 3). When
they mean "no" they say "That will be difficult"
or "We will have to give that further study" or
"That will be inconvenient". While Arabs lift
their eyebrows to politely refuse the request, Thais often
smile and change the subject or say nothing at all!
* Negotiators tend to be sensitive to issues of "face",
dignity, self-respect. Showing impatience, irritation, frustration
and anger are regarded to disrupt harmony and are considered
to be rude and offensive. They mask their negative emotions
by remaining expressionless or by putting a smile on their
face. And when negotiator on one side of the bargaining
table loses temper, both sides lose face.
* Their communication is "high context" i.e. the
meaning of what they are saying at the bargaining table
is often found more in the context surrounding the words
rather than in the words themselves.
* Directness and frankness in communication are equated
with immaturity and naivete - perhaps even arrogance. A
sincere friend is considered to be one who declares his
willingness to help out - even when he cannot or will not
do the favour.
Formal Vs informal business cultures
Breezy informality offends high status people from hierarchical
cultures just as the status-consciousness of formal people
may offend the egalitarian sensibilities of informal folks.
Attributes of formal culture:
* Tend to be organized in steep hierarchies that reflect
major differences in status, hierarchies, power and respect.
* Business contacts are formally addressed by their family
name and title and not by given name. Your Italian contact
should be addressed with the honorific "Commendatore"
until you know him well enough to call him Gustavo. And
your German contact Doctor Wilhelm Muller should be called
Herr Dr. Muller and never ever Willi.
* Formality in interpersonal communication is an important
way of showing respect and deference. Protocol rituals are
often numerous and elaborate. Innocent informality can be
easily misinterpreted as disrespect. For instance, bureaucrats
in South and South-east Asia can be offended by overly casual
behavior of the Westerners. Wearing a suit and tie to meetings
during the hot season sends a positive signal of respect
and keeping ones jacket on in a non-air-conditioned office
signals even greater respect.
|
Box 3
96,000 shirts that can't be sold
| When the Great Northern Apparel
of Toronto planned to import shirts from China,
the VP had categorically explained to the Evergreen
Garment of Guangzhow that any apparel sold in
Canada ought to have labels with fibre content
and laundering instructions in both French and
English. This news was a cause of concern in the
Chinese side because of their lack of expertise
in French. Too polite to say a precise "no",
the MD said "it might be difficult"
and "the question will require further study".
The VP of the Toronto firm reiterated that they
were left with no other option with this since
this was the law. He was then assured that "his
request will be given a serious consideration".
Relieved to have settled this final deal, the
VP signed the contract of purchase and went back
home. Several months later, a colleague called
him up to tell him that a shipment of 96,000 shirts
has arrived from China with bilingual labels in
English and Chinese. The VP did not know what
to do with 96,000 shirts that surely cannot be
sold due to lack of the right labels. |
|
* In certain hierarchically organized cultures women rarely
get senior positions in commercial organization. Especially
in South Korea, Japan and Saudi Arabia, men are traditionally
accorded higher status in the business world than females.
The top positions in most of the companies are held by men
who are not used to dealing with women in business on the
basis of equality. In Japan, for instance, almost all the
"office ladies" perform clerical duties and they
lack the status necessary to interact effectively with corporate
decision-makers.
* Age barrier is a matter of grave seriousness.
|
Box 4
| Formal
Cultures |
Informal
Cultures |
Most of Europe and
Asia
The Mediterranean region
Arab world Latin America |
Australia
USA
Canada
New Zealand
Denmark, Norway, Iceland |
|
Attributes of informal culture:
* People are uncomfortable with obvious status differences
that are, surely, smaller than those in the hierarchical
societies.
* One tends to address an acquaintance by his first name
too soon. Your prospective Australian business partner,
for instance, whom you happen to know only for a short while,
greets you with a hearty "G'day Phil! Let's 'ave a
beer!"
* Informal behavior is not regarded as disrespectful.
* Protocol rituals are relatively few and simple.
* Women in egalitarian cultures around the world are successful
entrepreneurs or executives in major corporations.
* Youth is an advantage.
Rigid and fluid time cultures
People look at time and scheduling differently in different
parts of the world. In rigid-time societies punctuality
is critical, schedules are set in concrete, agendas are
fixed and business meetings are rarely interrupted. Edward
T hall coined the word "monochronic" for these
clock-obsessed, schedule-worshipping cultures. And in direct
contrast are "polychronic" cultures, where people
place less emphasis on strict punctuality and are not obsessed
with deadlines. Polychronic cultures value loose scheduling
as well as business meetings where several meetings-within-meetings
may be taking place simultaneously.
|
Box 5
|
| Monochronic business
cultures |
Moderately monochronic |
Polychronic business
culture |
| Nordic and Germanic
Europe, North America, Japan |
Australia/New Zealand, Russia and most of East-Central
Europe, Southern Europe, Singapore, Hong Kong, Taiwan,
China, South Korea, South Africa |
The Arab World,
most of Africa, Latin America, South
and Southeast Asia |
Attributes of monochronic business culture:
* Punctuality and schedules are very important to business
people.
* Schedules and deadlines are very important. Tardiness
signals lack of discipline. Germans, for instance, feel
that if a man is ten minutes late for a meeting, he may
well be ten weeks late with his delivery.
* Meetings are seldom interrupted.
* Tend to follow agenda. Conversations proceed in a linear
fashion from Item 1 to the last item on the agenda with
no major digressions.
* Meeting starts off only with a few minutes of introductory
small talk.
Attributes of polychronic business culture
* People and relationships are more important than punctuality
and precise scheduling
* Schedules and deadlines tend to be quite flexible. Many
of them even tend to have an aversion towards rigid deadlines.
For instance, if ones Sicilian counterpart shows up
at all on the day of the meeting, he is considered to be
punctual. Wedding dinners are guaranteed to begin at least
two hours late in Singapore. Many Arab men believe that
it is impious and irreligious to try to see into the future;
terms like Insh'allah or "God willing" expressions
that belief.
|
Box 6
|
| Very expressive
cultures |
Variably expressive |
Reserved cultures |
| The Mediterranean
region, Latin Europe, Latin America |
USA, Canada, Australia, New Zealand, Eastern Europe,
South Asia, Africa |
East and Southeast
Asia, Nordic and Germanic Europe |
* Meetings are frequently interrupted.
* They do not always abide by an agenda. And if they do,
they may might as well start with item No. 5, proceed to
Item 3 and wander off in several directions.
* The introductory chat can last for several minutes. In
Italy or France, for example, the warm-up chat can really
be lengthy.
Expressive Vs Reserved nonverbal business behavior
Expressive people communicate in radically different ways
from their more reserved counterparts. This is true whether
they are communicating verbally, paraverbally and nonverbally.
The confusion that results from these differences can soil
our best efforts to market, sell, source, negotiate or manage
people across cultures. Thus the expressive/reserved divide
creates a major communication gap.
|
Box 7
World's prime culture zones
On the basis of the culture profile
the whole of the global market can be sliced into
eight prime culture zones. They are as follows:
1. Relationship-focused, formal, polychronic and
reserved Bangladesh, Indonesia, Malaysia, Vietnam,
Thailand, Philippines. India
2. Relationship-focused, formal, monochronic and
reserved Japan, China, South Korea, Singapore
3. Relationship-focused, formal, polychronic and
expressive Saudi Arabia, Egypt, Greece, Brazil,
Mexico
4. Relationship-focused, formal, polychronic and
variably expressive Russia, Poland, Romania
5. Moderately deal-focused, formal, variably monochronic
and expressive France, Belgium, Italy, Spain,
Hungary
6. Moderately deal-focused, formal, variably monochronic
and reserved The Baltic States
7. Deal-focused, moderately formal, monochronic
and reserved Britain, Denmark, Finland, Germany,
the Netherlands, Czech Republic
8. Deal-focused, informal, monochronic and variably
expressive Australia, Canada, USA |
|
Attributes of reserved business cultures
* People speak more softly, hardly interrupt each other
and are more comfortable with silence that is the case with
expressive cultures
* Expect interpersonal distance of about an arm's length
and little physical contact aside from the handshake.
* Avoid intense, continuous eye contact across the negotiating
table
* Expect very few hand and arm gestures and restrained facial
expression
Attributes of expressive business cultures
* People often speak quite loudly, engage in conversational
overlap and are uncomfortable with silence
* Expect interpersonal distance of half an arm's length
or less and considerable physical touching
* Direct, even intense eye contact across the negotiating
table signals interest and sincerity
* Expect lively facial expressions along with vigorous hand
and arm gesturing.
Highlighting notable differences in expression
Conversational overlap and the meaning of silence:
While expressive people regard "conversational overlap"
as a normal part of conversation, it is considered extremely
rude by people from reserved societies. For instance, Northern
European and North American negotiators are often frustrated
by the constant interruptions they experience while conducting
meetings in Italy, Spain or the former Yugoslavia. And the
Asian negotiators take turns in a sort of verbal table-tennis
match. Interestingly, the super-polite Japanese people not
only take turns to avoid overlap but they also go a step
further to pause five or ten seconds before taking their
conversational turn. They often sit without speaking for
what seems like an eternity to voluble Mexicans, Greeks
or Americans. After three or four seconds the latter feel
compelled to say something. Anything. To fill the silence.
Unfortunately the loquacity of expressive people irritate
the reticent Japanese, who seem to value the space between
the spoken words just as much as the words themselves and
who find their voluble counterparts rude and insulting.
On the other hand, the people from expressive cultures like
the Latins and Arabs tend to think that the Japanese are
at loss for words or are indecisive.
Distance behavior
Every human being is surrounded by an invisible envelope
of air called a space-bubble which varies in size according
to (a) where in the world we grew up and (b) the particular
situation. For instance, two Canadians who have just met
at a social event are likely to stand about an arm's length
away from each other. But he space bubble of the same two
Canadians shrink to zero when they are embracing. No spatial
problem exists as long as the people involve share similar-sized
comfort zones. The differences begin in cross-cultural situations
when different sized space bubbles collide. For instance,
the Arab men show their friendliness by nearly collapsing
in your arms. And, if you are a large bubble person, you
will probably instinctively step back by which you will
reflect your dislike towards him.
|
Box 8
Distance behaviour
| Close (20
to 35 cm) |
Distant
(40 to 60 cm) |
|
The Arab world, Mediterranean region,
Latin Europe,
Latin America
|
Most Asians, Northern, Central and Eastern
Europeans,
North Americans
|
|
Touching
Touch behavior regarded as proper in one culture may be
quite inappropriate in another. Differences in touch behaviors
are serious enough for problems to arise even between cultures
located fairly closer together on the map. For example,
the variation between the British and the French is surprisingly
large considering that these two European nations are separated
only by a channel of water. A couple of years ago, researchers
studied comparative touch behavior in Paris and London cafeterias
by counting the number of times couple touch each other.
They counted about 100 times in Paris and zero times in
London. While the British people think that the "moderate"
Americans do far too much shoulder-patting, elbow-grabbing
and back-slapping to please them, the Latin Americans often
accuse Yanks of being snobbish and stand-offish as, they
think, they do not engage in enough physical touching. Touching
in the corporate relationships by and large consists of
shaking hands and kissing.
Shaking hands
Among business people the world over the handshake is the
most common form of physical contact. See Box No. 9 for
a few of the variations.
|
Box 9
How hard should be the handshake
| Germans |
Firm, brisk,
frequent |
| French |
Light, quick
frequent |
| British |
Moderate |
| Latin |
Firm, frequent Americans |
| North |
Firm, infrequent Americans |
| Arabs |
Gentle, repeated, lingering |
| South Asians |
Gentle, often lingering |
| Koreans |
Moderately
firm |
| Most Asians |
Very gentle,
frequent |
|
Most Europeans shake hands each time they meet and again
when they take leave. North Americans shake hands less often
than Europeans but more firmly than most Asians. In Asia,
for men being introduced to female counterparts, one of
the few rules of etiquette that is most universally valid
is to wait for the woman to offer her hand.
Kissing
Non-Europeans visitors tend to be perplexed by the variety
of kissing rituals in the multicultural mosaic that is Europe.
Some of the guidelines are hereunder:
|
Box 10
Intense eye contact
The Arab World, the Mediterranean Region, Latin
European and Latin Americans
Firm eye contact
Northern Europe and North America
Moderate
Korea, Thailand, Most of the Africans
Indirect Eye contact
Most of Asia |
|
* Do not worry about kissing or being kissed the first
time you meet
* At subsequent meetings foreigners are excused from all
that promiscuous kissing if they do not wish to participate.
This will be a relief to many Asians who feel ill at ease
with the strange and embarrassing custom of kissing people
you barely know
* When kissing a woman's hand or cheek, you do not touch
the skin. Just kiss the air a few millimeters from her hand
or cheek. For kissing purposes space bubble shrinks considerably.
* The Brits usually kiss just once on the right cheek, the
French kiss twice (on the left and right) and the passionate
Belgians three times: left, right, left.
* Like the Italians and the Spanish, the reticent Germans
prefer to kiss a lady's hand instead of her cheeks
* For non-European women: When a man raises your hand to
his lips, just acknowledge the gallant gesture with a slight
smile.
* The male visitors to Russia feel uncomfortable when the
Russian men take them in their arms and kiss them on their
lips.
Eye contact
Perhaps the subtlest form of body language is gaze behavior.
We are easily confused when people use either stronger or
weaker eye contact than we do. Box No. 10 displays the variation.
|
Box 11
Meaning of raised eyebrows
| North Americans |
Interest,
surprise |
British
|
Scepticism |
| Germans |
You are clever! |
| Filipinos |
Hello |
| Arabs |
No! |
| Chinese |
Disagreement |
|
Very expressive cultures seem to value strong, direct eye
contact. While conversing with the Arabs, Turks and Latin
Europeans, one should look firmly in the eye. On the other
hand, the business visitors to East and Southeast Asia should
prepare themselves to encounter exactly the opposite style
of gaze behavior. There a direct gaze may be interpreted
as a hostile act. It might mean that you are trying to intimidate
them or provoke them to a fight. To avoid such problems,
some put on sunglasses. Unfortunately, that creates another
problem: In Southeast Asia, it is rude to have sunglasses
on when conversing with someone who is not wearing sunglasses.
Raised eyebrows
Negotiators are likely to encounter raised eyebrows in many
parts of the world. But flashing one's eyebrows sends different
signals in different cultures. In many a case the same expression
can have a different meaning - sometimes an opposite meaning
- in another culture (See box 11).
Thus, culture of a nation is soul deep. It runs through
the veins of its mortals. Gets inseparably woven into the
social, political and economic fabric of the land. And even
as globalization blurs the boundaries and distinctions between
nations, it grossly fails to sever man's ties with his land
and the culture to which he belongs. So when one deals with
people from the other part of the planet, one ought to take
cognizance of their habits, values, attitudes, sentiments
and expectations. And it is needful to remember that along
with creating invisible barriers to trade, cultural differences
may also pave way to new market opportunities. Only the
savvy marketer will know what it takes to make the international
customers tick.
The above article has been condensed/extracted from select
chapters of Cross-cultural Business Behavior by Gesteland,
Richard R., published by Viva Books Private Limited. All
rights of the authors and publisher are reserved